THE OVERLAY
Racing data

Are second favourites good value? We analysed 191,040 races

34%20%Fav2nd fav

By The Overlay teamCorrections

Updated 23 October 2026: re-run with a corrected method. What changed

The myth is tidy: everyone piles on the favourite, so the second favourite is the overlooked value bet. We tested it on 191,040 UK and Irish races. The myth does not survive contact with the data. Second favourites win about one race in five and lose you 13p in the pound at starting price, more than backing the favourite would.

"Back the second favourite" is one of those pub-wisdom systems that sounds clever because it sounds contrarian. The logic goes: the crowd over-bets the jolly, which shortens its price and leaves value on the next one in the market. It is a nice story. We have a database of UK and Irish results back to 2010, so in every race with a clear favourite we took the next-shortest runner at starting price as the second favourite: 191,040 races. Here is what actually happens.

20.2%
of races are won by the second favourite (191,040 races). Backing every one to level stakes at SP loses 13.0% of your money. The favourite loses too, but less: 8.1%.

So the second favourite wins a fraction over one race in five, and the market has it priced too short once the bookmaker's margin is in. Far from being the smart contrarian play, blindly backing the second favourite is a steady, predictable way to hand the bookmaker 13p in the pound.

The second favourite does worse than the favourite

Line up the top two in the betting. Win rate drops as you go down the market, and so does the return. There is no hidden pocket of value waiting at rank two.

Position in bettingRacesWin rateROI at SP
Favourite207,04034.0%-8.1%
Second favourite191,04020.2%-13.0%

Neither one makes money. The step down the market costs you a chunk of strike rate and about five more points of return. The crowd is not leaving value on the second favourite; the market has already done its job. Third-favourite figures are being re-run with the corrected method.

Does the second favourite's price change the answer?

Not in any way you can bet on. We split the second favourites by their own starting price to check whether a shorter or bigger-priced second favourite behaves differently. Every band loses.

Second favourite's priceRacesWin rateROI at SP
2/1 or shorter18,15632.7%-10.1%
Bigger than 2/1 to 4/1117,26321.4%-12.1%
Bigger than 4/1 to 8/154,84813.6%-15.9%
Bigger than 8/17737.8%-13.2%

All four bands lose, from 10.1% to 15.9% at SP. The shortest-priced second favourites lose least, and the 4/1 to 8/1 band loses most. A second favourite bigger than 8/1 is rare: 773 races out of 191,040, and it wins only 7.8% of them. An earlier version of this page showed a big profit in that band; that came from a method error and has gone in the re-run.

What this actually tells you

Market rank is not an edge. Backing the favourite blind loses about 8% at SP, and backing the second favourite blind loses more. Favourite, second favourite, third favourite: each is just a label for where the crowd has placed a runner, and the price already reflects that. Picking a horse because of its position in the betting, in either direction, is picking the market's opinion, and the market is, on average, right enough to keep your money.

An edge has to come from the gap between what a horse is genuinely worth and what it is being offered at. Sometimes that horse is the favourite, sometimes it is the second or third favourite, and most of the time the gap is not there at all and the race is best left alone. That is the part a "back the second favourite" rule can never tell you.

See fair odds on today’s races

Every runner’s fair odds beside 20+ bookmakers’ prices, and a flag when one bookmaker’s best price beats them. Most flagged horses still lose; we settle every flag in public. Free, no account. 18+, please bet responsibly.

Open the racecards

Related reading: Do favourites win in horse racing? and more racing data studies.

Method, in plain English

Every GB and Irish race from 1 January 2010 to 22 October 2026 where every runner had an official starting price and there was a winner: 207,040 races. The favourite is the shortest-priced runner at SP, fixed before the off; fallers, pulled-up and unseated favourites count as losers. Dead heats are paid by the dead-heat rule. ROI is level-stakes profit at SP per point staked. The second favourite is the shortest-priced runner after the favourite, and is only counted in races with a clear favourite (191,040 races; the 16,000 races with joint favourites are left out). Win rate is second-favourite wins divided by races. The favourite figure uses all 207,040 races, with joint favourites sharing the 1-point stake equally. Figures are historical and for information only.

More favourite studies: Favourite-longshot bias · Favourites by field size · Favourites by race class · Favourites: flat vs jumps · Favourites in handicaps · Favourites in maidens · The Favourite Report